1. Overall Weight: Poled + / Air –

Weight is one of the biggest differentiators between these two types of awnings.

1. oled Awnings: These tend to be heavier overall, but the weight is distributed between the frame and the canvas bag. As a result, a single person can more easily thread the awning onto the awning rail.

2. Inflatable Awnings: Since the inflatable frame is integrated into the awning fabric, the overall package is bulkier and heavier to drag along the awning rail.

Verdict: If portability and ease of handling are your priorities, poled awnings have the advantage.

2. Frame Assembly: Air + / Poled –

Setting up your awning is a key factor in determining how much effort you need to invest.

1. Poled Awnings: Assembling a 15-piece steel or aluminum frame is not an impossible task, but it requires more effort and time.

2. Inflatable Awnings: With an air awning, you simply plug in a 12V compressor or use a manual pump, and within minutes, your awning is fully erected.

Verdict: Inflatable awnings are the winner here, as they drastically reduce setup time and effort.

3. Storage & Moving: Poled + / Air –

Once packed away, the size and weight of your awning can make a difference, especially for those with limited storage.

1. Poled Awnings: Since the weight is distributed between the frame and the fabric, these awnings are much easier to handle and store in caravan compartments.

2. Inflatable Awnings: Even when packed into a holdall bag, inflatable awnings remain bulky and often do not fit into standard caravan storage spaces.

Verdict: If storage space is a concern, poled awnings are the more practical choice.

4. Pegging and Tensioning: Air + / Poled –

How easily can you achieve a perfectly pitched awning?

1. Poled Awnings: Proper tensioning requires fine adjustments to the frame’s height and position.

2. Inflatable Awnings: With the frame already integrated into the structure, achieving optimal tension is easier—just inflate to the manufacturer’s specifications and peg it down.

Verdict: Inflatable awnings provide a more straightforward pitching process, making them a winner in this category.

5. Price Consideration

While price wasn’t a factor in the above comparisons, it is an important aspect to consider.

1. Inflatable Awnings: Typically more expensive due to high-tech materials and innovative air-frame designs.

2. Poled Awnings: Generally more affordable while still offering great durability and performance.

Verdict: If budget is a key consideration, poled awnings offer better value for money.

Final Thoughts: Which One Should You Choose?

1. Choose a Poled Awning if: You prefer a more lightweight, compact, and budget-friendly option that’s easier to store and handle.

2. Choose an Inflatable Awning if: You want a hassle-free, quick setup and don’t mind the extra weight and price for added convenience.

Both types of awnings offer distinct advantages, so the right choice ultimately depends on your camping style, storage space, and budget.